Popular tips: "Try the vegan pizza with added vegan cheese, such as the Vegetable Lovers or Peppy Boy pizzas."
"Try the vegan pizza with added vegan cheese, such as the Vegetable Lovers or Peppy Boy pizzas."
"Visit when the patio is open for outdoor seating and a relaxed vibe."
"Expect higher prices for craft beers compared to typical tavern-style bars."
"Some popular non-vegan dishes include Buffalo wings and meatballs—stick to vegan pizzas to stay fully plant-based."
Must-try: pizza, dip platter, giardiniera dip
pizza — popular (×16)
dip platter — popular (×2)
giardiniera dip — popular (×2)
hippy flip pizza — popular (×2)
peppy boy pizza — popular (×2)
Praised for: friendly service, attentive service, fast service
friendly service ×8
attentive service
fast service
cozy atmosphere ×3
lively atmosphere
Dicey's Pizza & Tavern features Chicago-style tavern pizza with customizable vegan cheese options—particularly the Peppy Boy and Cacio e Pepe pizzas are often recommended. The venue combines a spacious, remodeled space with a bar and outdoor seating while also accommodating wheelchair users. Drink prices, especially for local craft beers, tend to be higher than typical tavern style spots, but the friendly service and casual atmosphere keep guests returning.