Skip to content

Photos via Google Maps

Mama Carolla's

Italian, Pasta Primavera

$$$

Top tips

Ask about: animal ingredients Ask about: uncertain ingredients

  • Expect long wait times during busy dinner hours.
  • Good to know: Ask staff carefully about ingredients as some vegan dishes contain hidden dairy or eggs.
All 3 tipsShow fewer
  • Enjoy the outdoor garden seating for a romantic dining experience.

People mention

No standout dish yet. People mention angel hair pasta, pasta and ravioli.

Good for

The vibe: dates The vibe: solo

Praised for friendly service.

Good to know

  • Outdoor seating
  • Dinner
  • Cards and mobile pay

About

Mama Carolla's is an upscale Italian restaurant set in a charming 1920s Mediterranean-style villa, known for its romantic ambiance and outdoor garden seating. The venue is popular for dinner and solo visits, with a full bar and an extensive wine list. However, vegan diners should note the limited and inconsistent vegan options, and some menu items contain hidden animal ingredients despite staff friendliness.

Visit

Open the map

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Opening hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
17:00–21:30
Wednesday
17:00–21:30
Thursday
17:00–21:30
Friday
17:00–21:30
Saturday
17:00–21:30
Sunday
Closed

the food

2.6 out of 5. Spinach Rating

From recent reviews, out of 5.

Google Maps
4.7 2,823 reviews Read on Google Maps
HappyCow
2.7 3 reviews Read on HappyCow
How we rank

eating vegan

Poor vegan options

vegan options
Few · 2–3 dishes
menu
Poorly marked
staff
Basic understanding
protein
mushrooms, veggies

Ask about: Hidden animal ingredients in dishes labelled vegan: ask about sauces and broths.

Ask about: Staff aren't always sure about ingredients.

Good to know: Vegan options aren't always available.

What the grades mean

nearby

More in Indianapolis

vegan food guide

indianapolis

The app is the full experience.

The live map, every ranking, and the dishes worth ordering.

  • free
  • no signup needed
The Spinach app: the Kraków map, each place with its rating and the dish worth ordering
in the app