Photos via Google Maps

NY Pizza Suprema

NY Pizza, Vegan Slices

Worth ordering: Pizzanamed in 29 reviews

4.6food Very vegan-friendly

Directions Menu

Website Call

Top tips

Ask which vegan slices are available that day; the by-the-slice selection rotates, while more varieties are available as whole pies.
Good to know: Arrive earlier in the evening if you want a vegan slice, since those slices can run out.

All 4 tipsShow fewer

Have your order ready at the counter, especially during busy periods; lines can reach the door even though they tend to move quickly.
Try the vegan white slice; one reviewer preferred it to the vegan NY regular.

People mention

White pizza and deep dish pizza.

Good for

The vibe: groups

Praised for friendly service, fast service and generous portions.

All 7 things people praiseShow fewer

Also praised for cozy atmosphere, beautiful interior, good value and lively atmosphere.

Good to know

Wi-Fi
Lunch, dinner, takeout, quick bites
Cards and mobile pay

About

Across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden, this old-school pizzeria has served New York-style slices since 1964, with a thin, crisp crust and several vegan varieties. Vegan slices rotate and may sell out; whole pies have more choices, while counter service is quick and seating can be tight when the line builds.