Photos via Google Maps

Proper Pie Co.

Savory & Sweet Pies, Vegan Pastry

Worth ordering: Pienamed in 30 reviews

Order early in the day as pies, especially vegan types, often sell out.

4.7food Good vegan options

Directions

Website Call

Top tips

Ask about: mislabelled dishes Ask about: uncertain ingredients

Good to know: Be aware that vegan chili pies and regular chili pies are not clearly distinguished on menu signage.
Look for vegan pies labeled with an “I’m vegan!” bag for added confidence.

All 4 tipsShow fewer

Enjoy your pies at nearby Libby Hill Park since seating at the shop is very limited.
No indoor seating or restrooms available; plan accordingly.

People mention

Apple pie, butter chicken pie and chicken mushroom leek pie.

All 9 dishes people mentionShow fewer

Also steak and cheese pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, cobbler, pastry, banoffee pie and cheddar and bean pie.

Good for

The vibe: work & study The vibe: relaxing

Praised for friendly service and fast service.

Good to know

Outdoor seating
Lunch, dessert, takeout, quick bites
Cards and mobile pay

About

Proper Pie Co. is a cozy takeout pie shop known for flaky New Zealand–style pies with a rotating menu including both meat and vegan options. Popular vegan pies like the vegan ricotta and mushroom and vegan cheddar and bean receive praise for their rich fillings and flaky crusts. Seating is limited to a few outdoor tables with no indoor dining; ordering ahead is advised as items frequently sell out.